Lawyer: Send the Judge to Prison-Chapter 417 - 386: Girls Help Girls? Gu Chen’s Interrogation!
Some netizens heard Xia Ranran say Liu Ting’s injuries were so severe.
Some netizens still stood by Liu Ting, but the vast majority supported Sun Yuxuan.
[Sun Yuxuan beating someone up like this is indeed a bit excessive, it’s a comminuted fracture of both legs, and he doesn’t have to pay a penny in compensation.]
[How to put it, the case turned out like this because of Liu Ting’s own issues. Sun Yuxuan can’t pay a penny, and that’s also Liu Ting’s problem. Liu Ting, you awarded all of Sun Yuxuan’s premarital assets to his ex-wife, and now you blame Sun Yuxuan for hitting you?]
[I think Sun Yuxuan is not at fault. He tried the proper channels, but it didn’t work. Sun Yuxuan couldn’t even survive anymore, so what else could he do?]
[It’s wrong for Sun Yuxuan to hit people, but does that make Liu Ting right? What gives Liu Ting the right to make such a judgment? Wasn’t it Sun Yuxuan’s ex-wife who cheated? If she hadn’t cheated, Sun Yuxuan wouldn’t have been so against her.]
[Sun Yuxuan doesn’t have a penny left; even his premarital assets were given to his ex-wife. I can’t take this anymore, over a million was all given to the woman, could you handle this?]
[Speed it up, I can only say, keep speeding it up.]
[Now they’re blaming Sun Yuxuan? What were they doing back then? It was wrong for Sun Yuxuan to hit people, but does that mean he should get a life sentence for it? Why doesn’t Sun Yuxuan compensate? Isn’t it because he has no money?]
[Good deeds will be rewarded, and evil deeds will incur consequences. Sun Yuxuan didn’t attack without reason, plus he turned himself in afterward. Should turning himself in still result in a life sentence? That’s excessive.]
[I also think it’s excessive, why should self-surrender get a life sentence? You say Sun Yuxuan doesn’t want to compensate? He doesn’t have a penny, you can’t blame him.]
[Laughing to death, hahaha, Liu Ting’s family actually asked Wang Ru for money, and Wang Ru just told Liu Ting’s family to get lost, hahaha, this is killing me.]
Xia Ranran’s remarks were indeed quite powerful.
But it was useless, many netizens supported Sun Yuxuan.
Sun Yuxuan made such a decision, and many netizens felt it was gratifying.
Why?
Because the previous judgment on Sun Yuxuan’s case was unreasonable!
It was simply pushing Sun Yuxuan into a corner!
Judge Gong Yuqing looked at Gu Chen and said, "Now please proceed with the defense."
Gu Chen began, "Your Honor, jury members, I need to state a fact to everyone."
"First, my client Sun Yuxuan broke someone’s legs, his behavior was indeed vile, and the consequences were indeed serious."
"However, all this had a cause."
Xia Ranran raised her hand and said, "No matter the cause, if Sun Yuxuan felt he was treated unfairly, that doesn’t justify hitting someone. If causes justify action, then every person who hits or kills has a reason. Should they be given leniency because of that?"
"In many murder cases, the defendant has a reason for killing, but the law is the law! Law and reason eclipse all. If special reasons justify killing, then what is the use of law?"
Xia Ranran looked into Gu Chen’s eyes.
Everyone looked at Xia Ranran.
Xia Ranran was indeed very adept in court, every sentence made sense.
Gu Chen spoke, "The law is indeed ironclad, but isn’t the purpose of the law to ensure fairness and justice?"
"But who ensured fairness and justice for Sun Yuxuan?"
"Sun Yuxuan hit someone, and it was wrong!"
"But there is one critical point here!"
"Sun Yuxuan didn’t lack remorse; he wanted to compensate and was willing to, but he didn’t have money, not a single penny!"
"Just before, Sun Yuxuan attended the second trial of his divorce case!"
"Liu Ting happened to be the judge!"
"And the result?"
"Sun Yuxuan’s ex-wife Wang Ru had been cheating for over a year!"
"Even before marriage, Wang Ru cheated multiple times with her ex-boyfriend!"
"The person Wang Ru cheated with gave the video to Sun Yuxuan!"
"It was Wang Ru’s infidelity that led to the family’s breakdown! Wang Ru’s cheating was the main reason for the divorce between Wang Ru and Sun Yuxuan!"
"But how did Liu Ting judge this case?"
"In divorce cases without children, the key point is asset division!"
"Post-marriage, Wang Ru didn’t earn a single penny!"
"Some might say Wang Ru was a housewife and housewives do contribute."
"Here’s footage, a total of 400 days worth! The footage documents Wang Ru’s daily life in detail!"
"In reality, Wang Ru never worked a day, never cooked a meal, never did any chores, when did she become a housewife? Is that the definition of a housewife?"
"After marriage, Sun Yuxuan handed over his paycheck every time, all his earnings went to her, Wang Ru didn’t earn a single penny a year after marriage. Rather than a housewife, she was being supported by Sun Yuxuan."
"And all of Sun Yuxuan’s house, car, everything was premarital property!"
"In this divorce case, Wang Ru cheated! She is at fault!"
"So, according to due litigation processes, the principles of favoring the innocent party should be applied, favoring the man’s rights during asset division."
"However, this point isn’t fixed by the law; it needs to be based on the specifics of the case."
"But how did Liu Ting rule?"
"All of Sun Yuxuan’s premarital assets ended up with Wang Ru in the form of a gift!"
"All post-marital assets also went to Wang Ru!"
"And at this time, Sun Yuxuan’s father suddenly fell ill and needed 200,000 yuan for surgery!"
"But Sun Yuxuan himself had savings! He had 500,000! He could save his father no matter what!"
"Because of Liu Ting’s judgment, Sun Yuxuan didn’t have money to save his father. He couldn’t come up with a single penny, but this money was earned through his hard work!"
"The final result was, Sun Yuxuan’s father died!"
"Is this reasonable?"
"This judgment was indeed according to the law."
"Because Liu Ting had a certain discretionary power."
"But is this result fair to Sun Yuxuan?"
"Did it really protect Sun Yuxuan’s rights?"
"Liu Ting, as a judge, didn’t actually do anything wrong."
"But..."
"I want to ask everyone a question."
"Do you think this is right?"
"Sun Yuxuan’s entire property was taken away!"
"Sun Yuxuan’s father left this world because of this!"
"Yet Liu Ting was delighted, she posted with a small account on Xiaohongshu—’girls help girls’, do you think this is right!!!"
