Once dinner was over, the girls told me to head to the master bedroom and wait until they called for me. I lay on the bed, casually scrolling through my phone. If this had been the old me, my heart would’ve been pounding like crazy. But now I felt surprisingly calm, excited, but not nervous.

After a few minutes of waiting, I got bored and stood up. I was only wearing a pair of black shorts. What the hell was taking them so long?

I quietly walked to the door and cracked it open. The girls were all huddled together in the kitchen, whispering and struggling with something. They were... wearing some costumes. And those were... some costumes, alright.

"This is so embarrassing..." Jasmine muttered.

"Let me try it," Tessa said.

I stepped out and stopped in my tracks at the sight in front of me.

Jasmine was wearing a full sexy black cat costume, a shiny, tight bodysuit that hugged every curve of her tall, voluptuous body. It had cute cat ears on her head. She looked incredibly hot, but she was clearly frustrated, struggling with a small metal canister that contained the matching buttplug with a fluffy tail.

The other girls had gone for different, equally seductive costumes:

Nala wore a deep red, extremely revealing babydoll lingerie set that barely covered her full breasts, the sheer fabric teasingly showing off her dark skin and hard nipples. Kim had chosen a delicate white lace corset and garter set that made her look both innocent and sinful at the same time.

Tessa was rocking a bold, orange micro bikini top with black shorts that were so tight they looked painted on, emphasizing her thick, juicy ass. Minne looked adorable yet arousing in a soft pastel blue sheer babydoll with little white bows, her petite body on full display.

Delilah had opted for an elegant emerald green satin robe that was open at the front, revealing matching lace lingerie underneath that barely contained her heavy breasts and wide hips. Eleanor completed the lineup in a silver-grey strappy bodysuit that wrapped around her graceful figure like ribbons, leaving very little to the imagination.

They were all trying, and failing, to open a small metal canister containing a buttplug with a fluffy cat tail attached.

"Fuck it," Jasmine exhaled. "Evan, come here please."

I pretended like I hadn’t been spying and opened the door fully. "Yeah?"

I walked into the kitchen and let out a low whistle.

"Well damn... kitty party?"

The girls turned to me with a mix of embarrassment and amusement. I picked up the stubborn canister, twisted the lid, and popped it open easily. Inside was a shiny black buttplug with a long, fluffy tail.

"Gah..." Jasmine exhaled. "I hate this."

"Jeez, calm down, kitty," I teased, pulling the plug out and examining the fluffy tail.

Tessa suddenly turned me around, grabbed the tail and gave me a playful push back toward the bedroom. "Okay, you go back now. We’ll come when we’re ready."

"Can’t wait," I grinned.

"I messed up the surprise..." Jasmine sighed.

"It’s fine," Delilah reassured her.

I walked back to the master bedroom, unable to stop smiling. They had gone through all this effort for me, even getting Delilah a costume. The realization that she had planned to be here made my chest feel warm. I was a lucky guy, huh?

"Damn... I really love these girls."

The bedroom door finally opened. The girls walked in one by one, looking incredibly sexy in their different outfits.

Jasmine came in last, wearing her black cat costume. She had the ears on, but she looked a little down. The fluffy tail buttplug was still in her hand, she hadn’t put it in yet. The other girls were smiling and excited, but Jasmine seemed hesitant.

"Surprise..." she said quietly, forcing a small smile.

I walked straight to her and pulled her into a big, warm hug. She hugged me back tightly, burying her face in my chest for a moment. I tilted her chin up and kissed her softly on the lips. Then I grabbed two big handfuls of her ass and squeezed, smacking it playfully as I kissed her again, deeper this time.

"What happened to that ’no anal’ thing?" I teased against her lips, playing with the base of the tail plug in her hand.

Jasmine sighed, looking a bit embarrassed. "Eleanor’s fault," she muttered, glancing at her. "Why would you even prepare for anal randomly like that? Kim was supposed to just bring you for dinner."

"I was going to visit Evan today anyway," Eleanor shrugged with a cute smile. "This dinner was just a coincidence."

"Lucky me," I grinned.

"Oh, luck wouldn’t even cover it, cowboy," Tessa smirked from the side.

I kissed Jasmine again, slower and deeper this time. I roughly grabbed her ass with both hands, squeezing hard before giving it a firm smack. Then I turned her around and bent her over the edge of the bed, her hands resting on the mattress.

I dropped to my knees behind her and spread her asscheeks wide. Her tight little hole was already twitching slightly. I leaned in and dragged my tongue slowly across it, tasting her clean skin. Jasmine shivered and let out a soft moan.

"Relax for me," I murmured, then licked her asshole again, slower and wetter this time. I circled her tight ring with my tongue, teasing and pressing against it before pushing my tongue inside. Jasmine gasped, her legs trembling.

"Oh fuck... Evan..." she breathed.

I ate her ass thoroughly, licking, sucking, and tongue-fucking her tight hole until it was shiny with my spit. I poured a generous amount of lube over her asshole and my fingers, then slowly worked one finger inside her. She was incredibly tight.

A few seconds later, I added a second finger, scissoring gently to stretch her while the other girls watched quietly from the side of the bed.

After a bit of fingering and licking, I stood up. I coated my hard cock with more lube and pressed the thick head against her glistening hole.

"Ready?" I asked softly, rubbing her lower back in slow, soothing circles.

Jasmine nodded, her breathing shaky. "Just... go slow at first, okay? Please."